ENEPIG vs ENIG: Which Surface Finish is Better?

RF & Microwave - 2 April 2024 - 3:50 am

Introduction

When it comes to selecting a surface finish for printed circuit boards (PCBs), there are several options to choose from. Two of the most popular surface finishes are ENEPIG (Electroless Nickel Electroless Palladium Immersion Gold) and ENIG (Electroless Nickel Immersion Gold). Both finishes offer excellent solderability, corrosion resistance, and shelf life, but they also have some key differences that may make one more suitable for a particular application than the other.

In this article, we will explore the differences between ENEPIG and ENIG, their advantages and disadvantages, and help you determine which surface finish is better for your specific needs.

Request RF PCB Manufacturing & Assembly Quote Now

What is ENEPIG?

ENEPIG is a surface finish that consists of three layers:

Electroless nickel (Ni) – This layer provides a barrier between the copper substrate and the outer layers, preventing diffusion and improving adhesion.
Electroless palladium (Pd) – This layer serves as a barrier between the nickel and gold layers, preventing corrosion and improving durability.
Immersion gold (Au) – This layer provides excellent solderability and protects the underlying layers from oxidation.

The typical thickness of each layer in the ENEPIG finish is:

Nickel: 3-6 µm
Palladium: 0.05-0.15 µm
Gold: 0.05-0.15 µm

Advantages of ENEPIG

Excellent solderability – The gold layer in ENEPIG provides superior wettability and solderability compared to other surface finishes.
Improved durability – The palladium layer in ENEPIG acts as a barrier, preventing the diffusion of nickel into the gold layer, which can lead to black pad syndrome in ENIG finishes.
High corrosion resistance – The combination of nickel, palladium, and gold layers in ENEPIG offers excellent corrosion resistance, making it suitable for harsh environments.
Longer shelf life – ENEPIG has a longer shelf life compared to ENIG, as the palladium layer prevents the growth of nickel oxide, which can degrade solderability over time.
Suitable for multiple reflow cycles – ENEPIG can withstand multiple reflow cycles without significant degradation in solderability or appearance.

Disadvantages of ENEPIG

Higher cost – The addition of the palladium layer in ENEPIG makes it more expensive than ENIG.
Longer processing time – The extra step of applying the palladium layer in ENEPIG increases the overall processing time compared to ENIG.
Potential for palladium corrosion – In some cases, the palladium layer in ENEPIG can be susceptible to corrosion, especially in the presence of sulfur-containing atmospheres.

What is ENIG?

ENIG is a surface finish that consists of two layers:

Electroless nickel (Ni) – This layer provides a barrier between the copper substrate and the outer layer, preventing diffusion and improving adhesion.
Immersion gold (Au) – This layer provides excellent solderability and protects the underlying nickel layer from oxidation.

The typical thickness of each layer in the ENIG finish is:

Nickel: 3-6 µm
Gold: 0.05-0.15 µm

Advantages of ENIG

Good solderability – The gold layer in ENIG provides good wettability and solderability, making it suitable for most soldering applications.
Lower cost – ENIG is less expensive than ENEPIG due to the absence of the palladium layer.
Shorter processing time – The ENIG process is faster than ENEPIG, as it does not require the additional palladium plating step.
Suitable for aluminum wire bonding – ENIG is compatible with aluminum wire bonding, making it a good choice for applications that require this type of interconnect.

Disadvantages of ENIG

Potential for black pad syndrome – ENIG is susceptible to black pad syndrome, a defect caused by the diffusion of nickel into the gold layer, which can lead to poor solderability and joint reliability.
Limited shelf life – The growth of nickel oxide on the surface of ENIG can degrade its solderability over time, resulting in a shorter shelf life compared to ENEPIG.
Not suitable for multiple reflow cycles – ENIG may not perform well in applications that require multiple reflow cycles, as the repeated exposure to high temperatures can degrade the finish and lead to solderability issues.

ENEPIG vs ENIG: A Comparison

To help you better understand the differences between ENEPIG and ENIG, we have compiled a comparison table highlighting the key aspects of each surface finish:

Aspect	ENEPIG	ENIG
Layers	Nickel, Palladium, Gold	Nickel, Gold
Solderability	Excellent	Good
Durability	High	Moderate
Corrosion Resistance	Excellent	Good
Shelf Life	Longer	Shorter
Multiple Reflow Cycles	Suitable	Not suitable
Cost	Higher	Lower
Processing Time	Longer	Shorter
Aluminum Wire Bonding	Not compatible	Compatible
Potential Issues	Palladium corrosion in sulfur-containing atmospheres	Black pad syndrome, degradation of solderability

When to Choose ENEPIG

ENEPIG is the preferred surface finish in the following situations:

High-reliability applications – ENEPIG’s excellent durability and corrosion resistance make it suitable for high-reliability applications, such as aerospace, military, and medical devices.
Harsh environments – The combination of nickel, palladium, and gold layers in ENEPIG provides superior protection against corrosion, making it a good choice for applications exposed to harsh environments.
Multiple reflow cycles – If your application requires multiple reflow cycles, ENEPIG is the better choice, as it can withstand repeated exposure to high temperatures without significant degradation in solderability or appearance.
Long shelf life requirements – ENEPIG has a longer shelf life compared to ENIG, making it suitable for applications that require extended storage periods before assembly.

When to Choose ENIG

ENIG is the preferred surface finish in the following situations:

Cost-sensitive applications – If cost is a primary concern, ENIG may be the better choice, as it is less expensive than ENEPIG due to the absence of the palladium layer.
Shorter processing time – ENIG has a shorter processing time compared to ENEPIG, as it does not require the additional palladium plating step. This can be advantageous when faster turnaround times are needed.
Aluminum wire bonding – If your application requires aluminum wire bonding, ENIG is the better choice, as it is compatible with this type of interconnect.
Lower-reliability applications – For applications that do not require the highest level of durability and corrosion resistance, ENIG may be a suitable and cost-effective choice.

FAQs

Q: Can ENEPIG be used for wire bonding?
A: ENEPIG is generally not recommended for wire bonding, as the palladium layer can interfere with the bonding process. If wire bonding is required, ENIG is the better choice, particularly for aluminum wire bonding.
Q: How does the cost of ENEPIG compare to other surface finishes?
A: ENEPIG is one of the more expensive surface finishes due to the addition of the palladium layer. It is typically more costly than ENIG, OSP (Organic Solderability Preservative), and HASL (Hot Air Solder Leveling).
Q: Can ENIG be used in high-reliability applications?
A: While ENIG can be used in some high-reliability applications, it may not be the best choice for applications that require the highest level of durability and corrosion resistance. In these cases, ENEPIG is often the preferred surface finish.
Q: What is black pad syndrome, and how does it affect ENIG?
A: Black pad syndrome is a defect that can occur in ENIG surface finishes, caused by the diffusion of nickel into the gold layer. This can lead to poor solderability and joint reliability. The palladium layer in ENEPIG helps prevent this issue.
Q: How does the shelf life of ENEPIG compare to ENIG?
A: ENEPIG has a longer shelf life compared to ENIG, as the palladium layer prevents the growth of nickel oxide, which can degrade solderability over time. ENIG is more susceptible to solderability degradation during extended storage periods.

Conclusion

Choosing between ENEPIG and ENIG surface finishes depends on several factors, including the specific requirements of your application, cost considerations, processing time, and compatibility with other assembly processes like wire bonding.

ENEPIG offers superior durability, corrosion resistance, and solderability, making it the preferred choice for high-reliability applications and harsh environments. It also has a longer shelf life and can withstand multiple reflow cycles. However, ENEPIG is more expensive and has a longer processing time compared to ENIG.

ENIG, on the other hand, is a cost-effective option with a shorter processing time. It is compatible with aluminum wire bonding and suitable for applications that do not require the highest level of durability and corrosion resistance. However, ENIG is susceptible to black pad syndrome and has a shorter shelf life compared to ENEPIG.

Ultimately, the decision between ENEPIG and ENIG should be based on a careful evaluation of your specific application requirements and priorities. By understanding the advantages and disadvantages of each surface finish, you can make an informed decision that ensures the best performance, reliability, and cost-effectiveness for your PCB Assembly.

CATEGORIES:

RF PCB

Tags:

No tags